How to be Profitable at Any Size, with Drew McLellan — Ep. 217

About this Episode

In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel Petitpas is joined by Drew McLellan, founder of Agency Management Institute, to unpack what profitability really looks like at different stages of agency growth. Drawing on decades of experience and financial data from more than 250 agencies, Drew explains why every agency can be profitable—regardless of size—and why many owners mistakenly believe their stage makes profitability impossible. Together, they explore common growth “breaking points,” the tradeoffs between lifestyle businesses and scalable firms, and why running an agency by the numbers is non-negotiable. From the realities of hiring, specialization, and management layers to how AI is reshaping what agencies should actually charge for, this conversation gives agency owners a grounded, experience-driven roadmap for building a more resilient, profitable business—without chasing hype or false benchmarks.

Watch this Episode

Points of Interest

• 00:00 – 02:00 – Why Agencies Avoid Talking About Money: Drew reflects on why financial transparency was rare in agencies historically and why that silence created widespread confusion about profitability.
• 02:00 – 05:00 – The Myth of “Impossible” Profitability: Drew explains why claims that an agency “can’t be profitable” usually stem from avoided decisions, misunderstood agency math, or intentional lifestyle choices.
• 05:00 – 07:30 – Agency Growth Breaking Points: Drew outlines common headcount thresholds where systems, processes, and structure begin to break down as agencies grow.
• 07:30 – 10:00 – Challenges of Very Small Agencies: The conversation explores why sub-10-person agencies struggle with inefficiency, tribal knowledge, and inconsistent delivery.
• 10:00 – 13:00 – Generalists vs. Specialists: Drew explains why early-stage generalists often struggle as agencies scale and why specialization becomes essential for profitability.
• 13:00 – 15:30 – Management Layers and Cost Pressure: Marcel and Drew discuss how introducing management roles adds financial strain and operational complexity.
• 15:30 – 17:30 – The Most Profitable Agency Size Range: Drew shares data showing agencies with 15–40 employees consistently outperform others on profitability.
• 17:30 – 19:30 – Why Growing Up Improves Margins: The episode breaks down how systems, niching, and client selection drive efficiency and longer tenure at mid-size agencies.
• 19:30 – 22:00 – Bigger Agencies, Bigger Expectations: Drew explains how larger clients demand higher sophistication, better talent, and increased operational investment.
• 22:00 – 25:00 – Lifestyle Businesses vs. Scalable Agencies: The conversation reframes success, validating highly profitable small agencies that are never intended to be sold.
• 25:00 – 28:00 – Running the Business by the Numbers: Drew and Marcel align on first principles like AGI and the 55-25-20 model as the foundation for healthy decision-making.
• 28:00 – 37:00 – AI, Commoditization, and the Future of Agencies: Drew connects decades of industry evolution to today’s AI shift, arguing that strategy, thinking, and leadership—not production—are the true sources of agency value.

Show Notes

• Connect with Drew via LinkedIn
• AMI
• • Website
  • Newsletter
  • Podcast

Love the Podcast

Leave us a review here.