How to Leverage M&A as a Growth Strategy for your Agency, with Matt Bodnar — Ep.145
About this Episode
In this episode, Marcel sits down with Matt Bodnar, a “Forbes 30 Under 30” alum and Founding & Managing Partner at Eidolon Capital, to dive into the world of mergers and acquisitions in the agency space. Matt, a seasoned entrepreneur and investor, shares his expertise on growing businesses through strategic acquisitions and scaling. He discusses the crucial role of deal structure and creative financing in successful mergers and explains how AI is reshaping agency valuations.
Matt’s real-world experiences and stories provide valuable insights for business owners aiming to expand via partnerships and acquisitions. This episode is packed with practical advice and strategic tips for anyone navigating that complex landscape.
Tune in to the episode below!
Watch this Episode
Points of Interest
- 00:54 – 01:39 – Matt’s Journey: Matt Bodnar shares his background, mentioning his experience at Goldman Sachs and his move to Nashville in 2011, where he bought his first IT service company.
- 02:24 – 03:07 – M&A Realization: Matt explains how he stumbled into mergers and acquisitions and the importance of creative deal structures and the independent sponsor model.
- 05:00 – 06:29 – Independent Sponsor Model: Matt discusses the independent sponsor model, which involves raising capital on a deal-by-deal basis, allowing him to start doing deals without needing a large fund.
- 07:02 – 08:32 – Business Giveaway Deal: Matt shares an example of a ‘business giveaway’ deal where they acquired a data center, paying the seller a percentage of revenue over a few years, which was beneficial for both parties.
- 08:33 – 10:42 – Cross-Selling Opportunities: Matt explains the benefits of cross-selling between the acquired data center and his existing IT business, which led to increased revenue and new opportunities.
- 10:43 – 13:42 – Roll-Up Dynamics: Marcel talks about the concept of roll-up deals, using an example from the pharmacy space, and discusses the potential for similar strategies in the agency space.
- 13:43 – 19:06 – Market Environment: Matt shares his perspective on the current market environment, emphasizing that interest rates are less of a concern than the impact of AI on agency valuations and M&A activity.
- 19:07 – 23:51 – Creative Deal Structures: Matt discusses the importance of creative deal structures in mitigating risks and adapting to various market conditions, especially in the agency space.
- 27:16 – 29:08 – Integration Challenges: Marcel and Matt discuss the challenges of integrating acquired businesses, with Matt emphasizing the importance of having a good operating infrastructure.
- 30:50 – 33:58 – Understanding Seller Needs: Matt stresses the importance of understanding the seller’s goals and desires to craft effective deal structures that work for both parties.
- 33:59 – 36:04 – Structuring Deals: Matt provides examples of different deal structures, such as non-voting stock and liquidity preferences, to illustrate how creative approaches can facilitate complex acquisitions.
Show Notes
Connect with Matt through:
Love the Podcast
Leave us a review here.
Written by
Parakeeto
Free Resource
Get the Agency Profitability Toolkit
Free tools, templates, and training videos to measure the right metrics and improve your profitability.
Free Consultation
Ready to Improve Your Agency's Profitability?
Schedule a free consultation with a profitability expert to find out how much money you're leaving on the table.
Free ConsultationRelated Posts

Insights from Europe on Global Competition, Talent, and AI, with Carson Pierce — Ep.194
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel is joined Parakeeto’s Operations Consultant – Carson Pierce to unpack insights from Marcel’s recent trip to Web Summer Camp in Croatia, a gathering of highly technical agencies from across Europe. Drawing from conversations with founders in the Balkans and Eastern Europe, they explore […]

Building Trust at Scale in the Age of AI, with Stephen Woessner — Ep. 203
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel sits down with Stephen Woessner, CEO & Founder of Predictive ROI and author/podcaster with 30 years in the industry, to unpack how agencies can win in a low-trust, AI-noisy market by selling with authority. Stephen shares why trust now starts below zero and […]

The Legal Risks of AI in Agency Work, with Sharon Toerek — Ep.213
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel is joined by long-time agency legal expert and Innovative Agency host Sharon Toerek to unpack one of the most urgent but confusing topics facing firms right now: the legal and business implications of AI. Drawing on decades of experience representing creative and digital […]

How to Build an Anti-Fragile Agency, with Brent Weaver — Ep. 219
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel sits down with Brent Weaver, founder of UGURUS and now CEO of E2M Solutions, to unpack a timely idea for agency owners staring down constant disruption, how to build a business that gets stronger when things change. Brent shares his journey from selling […]

How to be Profitable at Any Size, with Drew McLellan — Ep. 217
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel Petitpas is joined by Drew McLellan, founder of Agency Management Institute, to unpack what profitability really looks like at different stages of agency growth. Drawing on decades of experience and financial data from more than 250 agencies, Drew explains why every agency can […]

From Losing Money to Strong Profits – Real Case Client Study, with Carson Pierce — Ep. 206
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel sits down with long-time Parakeeto consultant Carson Pierce to pull back the curtain on a real (anonymized) client assessment and show exactly how agencies can diagnose stubborn profit issues. Drawing on insights from 100+ assessments, Carson walks through the step-by-step process—starting with a […]

Top-Down vs Bottom-Up Forecasting, with Kristen Kelly –Ep.184
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel sits down with Parakeeto’s own Kristen Kelly to tackle the often misunderstood and overly complex topic of forecasting in service businesses. They break down the difference between bottom-up and top-down forecasting, explaining how each serves a different purpose, from granular project planning to […]

Where CFO Meets COO: Parakeeto’s Unique Approach to Profitability, with Carson Pierce — Ep. 218
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel Petitpas is joined by Parakeeto’s consultant Carson Pierce for a candid, behind-the-scenes conversation about one deceptively simple question: what does Parakeeto actually do? Sparked by public feedback on LinkedIn, Marcel and Carson unpack Parakeeto’s evolving positioning as the world’s first profit management firm—and […]

How to Improve Handoffs from Sales to Delivery, with Kristen Kelly — Ep. 214
About this Episode In this episode of the Agency Profit Podcast, Marcel is joined once again by Kristen Kelly to unpack one of the most persistent friction points inside service businesses: the handoff between sales and delivery. Drawing on her experience working with agencies of all sizes, Kristen breaks down the all too familiar pattern […]


